Black Friday is America’s sale. The day after Thanksgiving has been retail’s biggest moment for decades, Cyber Monday was invented to give online stores a slice of it, and the rest of the world has spent the last ten years copying both. If the sale has a home crowd, this is it.
So we started here. In October 2026, Tracksuit surveyed 690 US adults about Black Friday and Cyber Monday (BFCM), and 64% said they’d either bought in last year’s BFCM sales or were open to doing so. Scaled up to the adult population, that equates to roughly 178 million people, by far the largest pool of engaged shoppers in our seven-country study.
The 64% of respondents who qualified as BFCM shoppers rated 15 major retailers: the global marketplaces (Amazon, eBay, Temu, Shein and AliExpress) and ten American retail brands that between them cover general merchandise, electronics, home improvement, department stores and beauty (Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Costco, Home Depot, Lowe’s, Macy’s, Ulta Beauty, Sephora and Wayfair). In every other market we surveyed, this is where Amazon runs away with it. In the United States, it has company.
Black Friday has a reputation as a free-for-all of bigger discounts, earlier deals and increasingly louder attempts to get shoppers to hit ‘buy now’. It’s an easy conclusion to reach when discounts dominate the conversation. What American shoppers told us goes deeper. The retailers they prefer are strong on two things at once. They have mental availability, meaning shoppers know them and would consider them, and physical availability, meaning shoppers can find and acquire items easily. So while discount culture may feel like a race to the bottom, people are racing to the strongest brands, and in the US two of them are way out in front.
We’ll kick this analysis off with who is winning on purchase and preference, then how mental and physical availability line up behind the brand that wins, and the wider brand picture behind it. The retailers that win are the ones that turn “I’d consider it” into “I bought it”, and then into “I’ll be back next year”.
Remember what we’re reading here: this is shoppers’ state of mind going into Black Friday 2026, not what happens during it. We’ll follow up in January with three months of data and the full story. Here’s what we found.
Amazon leads the race. Walmart is close enough to matter
Ask Americans to name a BFCM retailer off the top of their head and 59% say Walmart, ahead of Amazon at 55%. But ask which retailer they’d prefer to buy from and it flips: 44% say Amazon, 19% say Walmart, with Target next at 8%.
Walmart wins at coming to mind. Amazon wins at being chosen. Even so, Walmart is the closest any US retailer gets to Amazon. It’s known as a BFCM retailer by 82% of shoppers (Amazon 87%), considered by 60% (Amazon 75%) and bought from during BFCM last year by 44% (Amazon 60%). The repeat BFCM purchasing habit is real too: 26% of people who know Walmart for BFCM say it’s where they shop every Black Friday, the highest of any non-Amazon retailer in our study.
Sign up for Shorts
For fortnightly brand insights, stories and goodness that’ll help you win (we promise).
From shortlist to basket: Walmart keeps up until shoppers checkout
The US is the one market where a rival gets close to Amazon at the checkout as well as in the minds of shoppers. Walmart goes from 82% awareness to 60% consideration to 44% bought, against Amazon’s 87% awareness, 75% consideration and 60% bought. Target follows at 50% considered and 27% bought. After that the drop is steep: Best Buy is considered by 43% and bought by 16%, Costco by 29% and 10%. Purchase and preference are counted differently, which is why the gap between them is so telling: shoppers could select multiple retailers when we asked who they’d bought from last year, while only one retailer can be selected as their preferred choice.
Awareness and consideration are how we read mental availability. Amazon keeps more shoppers moving at every stage, but Walmart comes closest: 86% of the people who know Amazon for BFCM consider it (Walmart 73%), 81% of those who consider it bought from it (Walmart 72%), and 73% of those who bought from it prefer it (Walmart 44%).

Between them, Amazon and Walmart take 63% of first preferences, and after Target and Best Buy every other retailer is bought from by 10% of shoppers or fewer. US shoppers bought from an average of 2.2 of the 15 major retailers we surveyed, the second most of the eight markets after France (2.4). Amazon accounts for 28% of all the purchases Americans reported across those 15. This is a sale people shop around.
Walmart has the price. Amazon has the physical availability machine
We asked Black Friday shoppers which of 13 qualities they associate with each retailer, from reliable shipping and ease of use to trust and value, counting only people who already know the brand. Two things to keep in mind. Shoppers could pick more than one statement for each retailer, so “has the best deals” isn’t a preference, but it’s a strong sign of where shoppers see value. And the charts weight each score by how many BFCM shoppers know the retailer, which makes retailers with different reach more comparable. Four qualities stood out as most closely linked to retailer preference across our seven markets, and Amazon leads all four in the US.
Among people who know Amazon from BFCM, 62% call it easy to use (Walmart 42%), 49% associate it with a wide range of deals (Walmart 48%), 40% say it has the best deals (Walmart 32%, Costco 27%) and 63% say its shipping is reliable (Walmart 31%). This is a stark contrast with the average across the other 14 competitor brands, at 19% (reliable shipping), 14% (fast shipping), and 40% on product variety.
Walmart’s strength is price, and it’s a strong one. Among people who know Walmart for BFCM, 63% call it affordable, more than any other retailer we asked about, against 48% for Amazon, and 53% say it’s good value for money (Amazon 49%). By contrast, the average association with these statements across the other 13 brands was 24% (affordable) and 25% (good value for money).
Across all BFCM shoppers, 52% both know Walmart and call it affordable, against 42% for Amazon.
On preference, 44% of BFCM shoppers say they’d prefer Amazon, against 19% for Walmart.
What makes Walmart the one genuine second choice in the US is that it holds more of the machine than any other challenger. Across all BFCM shoppers it is second to Amazon on all four qualities, and within four points on range of deals (39% against 43%), though well behind on best deals (26% against 35%), easy to use (34% against 54%) and reliable shipping (25% against 55%).
Trust belongs to neither. Amazon has the biggest trusting audience (40% of all BFCM shoppers), ahead of Target (34%), Walmart (31%) and Home Depot (29%). Among people who know them, Home Depot (48%) and Costco (46%) match Amazon (46%) on trust, but fewer shoppers know them, and none of that trust shows up in preference (Home Depot 2%, Costco 5%, Lowe’s under 1%). Trust is shaped by many things beyond Black Friday, so this isn’t a BFCM-only read.
Target doesn’t lead on anything, which is why it’s a clear third rather than a rival.
The takeaway? Walmart already holds some of what makes Amazon successful. The challenge is bringing the rest together.
The chart below weights each score by how many shoppers know the retailer, so the total responses per retailer are comparable. That is why its figures read lower than the ones above, which are among people who know each brand.

Temu and Shein have attention, not brand
In the US, the Asia headquartered marketplaces have the name but not the pull. Temu is recognized as a BFCM retailer by 43%, considered by 13%, was bought from by 8% during BFCM last year and is preferred by under 2%. Shein follows a similar pattern at: 36%, 10%, 5% and under 1%. Together with AliExpress they hold 3% of first preferences. Temu’s 8% is still around 13.7 million US adults, level with Macy’s (7.5%) and ahead of Lowe’s (5.1%) and Wayfair (2.1%).
The chart below sets Temu and Shein beside Amazon and the average of the ten US retailers at each stage, from awareness through to preference.

One explanation sits in Arkansas. Walmart already has the low-price offer, with much more of the machine around it. Among people who know each brand, 32% say Walmart has the best deals against 14% for Temu, 42% call Walmart easy to use against 25%, and 31% say its shipping is reliable against 13%. Trust is 38% against 13%. Weighted by how many shoppers know each brand, the gap is wider still: about 6% of BFCM shoppers both know Temu and say it has the best deals, against 26% for Walmart. Temu has bought attention. It hasn’t yet built a reason for Americans to pick it first.
Against the ten retail brands on our list, Temu is known for affordability: 37% of people who know it call it affordable, against 28% for the average one. On deals it trails: among people who know Temu, 22% associate it with a wide range of deals (36% for the ten) and 14% with the best deals (16%).
Temu and Shein are also falling behind on awareness, consideration and trust.
Temu is known by 43% of BFCM shoppers and Shein by 36%, against 62% for the average of the ten. Just 13% and 10% consider them, against 31%. And among people who know Temu, only 13% call it a brand they trust, against 37%.
The takeaway? Getting attention is one thing. Turning it into trust, consideration and purchases is another.
How Americans are heading into the sale
Americans are heading into the sale with a routine, and most of the decision has already been made. Amazon and Walmart have claimed the first-preference vote between them, and they’re the two names shoppers say they come back to every Black Friday. Target, in third, is the only other retailer with a real foothold.
It’s also a shopper who buys from a couple of retailers on average. So this is a shopper with a plan for where each item will come from, and a second basket for anyone who earns it.
It’s a race to the brand, and in the US two brands are way out in front. Walmart is close to Amazon on mental availability (known by 82% against 87%, considered by 60% against 75%) and level with it on range of deals (48% against 49%), but Amazon holds the rest of the physical side, and it still leads on preference by a wide margin.
What this means if you’re racing against Amazon
Mental and physical availability win the sale together. The US shows what a challenger can build, and Walmart’s playbook is the template: be the first name that comes to mind, hold more of the machine than anyone else on your shelf, and turn it into a tradition. That’s built over a long time, and there might not be time to overhaul your entire strategy before the peak, but some small adjustments can still go a long way:
- Lead with one reason to choose you. Target doesn’t lead on anything, which is why it’s a clear third rather than a rival. Walmart is second because shoppers know what it stands for. Pick the one thing you can credibly claim this fortnight and say it everywhere you show up.
- Make buying easy, and make delivery as loud as the discount. Easy to use and reliable shipping are two of the four qualities that line up most closely with preference, and they’re where Amazon’s lead over Walmart is widest. Where relevant, say when it arrives, what happens if it doesn’t, and how easy returns are.
- Turn trust into a reason to buy. Several retailers are as trusted as Amazon among the people who know them, and almost none of that trust has turned into preference. If you’re on the shortlist, turn trust into a reason to buy this weekend, not just to browse.
- Treat the weeks after as the window to build repeat BFCM purchasing habit. Email, loyalty offers and a reason to come back in 2027 are how this year’s buyers become next year’s regulars, and the routine Amazon and Walmart hold is what that looks like.
Two weeks out, the US is a race to the brand, and two names are way out in front. Amazon and Walmart hold the first-preference vote and the routine of coming back every Black Friday, and Walmart shows that a challenger can build mental availability and a good share of the physical side. For everyone else, the job is to pick the pieces you can credibly own, from ease of use to delivery to trust, and make them easy to see. The part of this that outlasts the sale is that routine, and it’s what we’ll be watching when we circle back in January with three months of data.
Methodology
Part of Tracksuit’s seven-country Before Black Friday 2026 study. Read the global view here: [Link: global post].
In October 2026 Tracksuit surveyed 690 US adults. Respondents qualified as BFCM shoppers if they said they had bought in a Black Friday or Cyber Monday sale in the past 12 months or were open to buying in this year’s sale; 442 did. Unless stated, results are shares of the 442 BFCM shoppers in the US, rounded to whole numbers, so totals and differences may not add exactly.
BFCM shoppers rated 15 major retailers in their market on four measures: awareness (recognising the retailer as a BFCM retailer), consideration (would consider buying from it), bought (bought from it in last year’s BFCM, with as many choices as they liked) and preference (the one retailer they would most prefer to buy from this BFCM). Conversion between stages, such as “86% of the people who know Amazon for BFCM consider it”, divides one stage by the one before, using each stage’s share of all BFCM shoppers. Unprompted awareness (naming a BFCM retailer without being shown a list) is also used in this post.
Retailers per shopper adds each market’s purchase rates across the 15 retailers, and a retailer’s share of purchases is its purchase rate divided by that total.
Brand perception statements are asked of people aware of each brand: they chose which of 13 short statements fit each retailer, and could choose more than one statement for each retailer, so statement scores are shares of aware shoppers and are not a preference measure. Where we weight statements by awareness, we multiply the share of aware shoppers choosing a statement by the share of BFCM shoppers who know the retailer, and show the result as a share of all BFCM shoppers, so that the share of the population who hold each view is more evident. Statement results are used only for retailers with at least 100 aware respondents.
Brand statements and preference: we used Spearman’s rank correlation to identify the strongest connection points between the brand statements and the funnel metrics, across the 101 retailer-and-market pairs with at least 100 aware respondents in the seven-market analysis.
The Temu and Shein comparison sets each against the average of the ten US retailers (the 15 less Amazon, eBay, Temu, Shein and AliExpress), using statements only where at least 100 people were aware of the brand.
Each retailer appears once per market and the pairs aren’t fully independent, so the figures describe the pattern rather than test for cause.
Retailer groups: the 15 major retailers are grouped as US-headquartered marketplaces (Amazon and eBay); marketplaces headquartered in Asia (Temu, AliExpress and Shein); beauty (Ulta Beauty, plus French-headquartered Sephora); electronics and appliances (Best Buy); general merchandise (Walmart and Target); department stores (Macy’s); home improvement (Home Depot and Lowe’s); home and furniture (Wayfair); warehouse clubs (Costco). Unless marked, brands are headquartered in the US.
Population equivalents apply each market’s rounded engagement rate to the UN World Population Prospects 2024 (medium variant) estimate of the population aged 18 and over at 1 July 2026.
We’ll publish a follow-up in January, using a full three months of data, on how the sale actually played out.
AI was used to support ideation and iteration of this analysis. All data points and observations have been refined and validated by Tracksuit’s Marketing Science team.



